Mallie McKenzie spent five years as a member of the University of Georgia Bulldogs, where she recorded six goals, and 22 assists, which put her fourth on the all-time program list for assists. During her graduate season, McKenzie set a program record for appearances, playing in 98 matches for the Bulldogs. This past season McKenzie helped Georgia earn its first-ever Southeastern Conference (SEC) Title, earning herself a spot on the 2023 SEC All-Tournament Team.